- Sensibility: Some aspects of the faith, particularly around children and the gathering of new members is odd, but on the whole the film is surprisingly sensible.
- Cinematography: Beautiful imagery propelled by excellent production design and costuming. Lighting is excellent. However, there are some inconsistency with aging techniques and a few sequences in the film, notably a scene finding the land for the settlement, that stick out from the rest of the film.
- Energy: The film is so jam-packed with energy that is might lead to shaking. The beginning of the film is so strong and interesting that the back half may seem a bit flat on the whole. Other than an awkward bit about finding settlement land and the death of an old friend, the film and its narrative proceed seamlessly.
- Narrative: A musical that is a brilliant story first. The interplay of the songs with the narrative is seamless, so the musical numbers aren't bothersome or obtuse. The narration and dialogue are excellent and
add to the mystical and ancient feel of the film. However, a large swathe of the film around the middle drags pursuing elements of the story that don't directly pertain to Ann Lee, who is, without a doubt, the most interesting and
well performed character in the story.
- T-Points: The film received three bonus points: one for an early shakerism sequence, one for a sequence and set of visions while Ann is imprisoned, and one for a praise sequence on the bow of a ship.
This film stayed with me for days after finishing. It's not a film for everyone and it definitely has its flaws, but this film is a shining example of what a great musical film should be.
Number of Watches: 1
